business-image-0
business-image-1
business-image-2
business-image-3

Dudley's Toffee

Handcrafted English almond toffee made in small batches with a cherished family recipe. Rich, buttery flavor with a softer texture that won’t stick to your teeth.

Local. Fair. Trusted. All in one place.

  • Meet Brian

    Founder of Dudley's Toffee, Beech Grove, INHi, I’m Brian Stout, founder of Dudley’s Toffee. We handcraft small-batch English almond toffee in Indiana with a softer buttery crunch that won’t stick to your teeth.

  • Loyaltie Protection Promise

    Enjoy every purchase with total confidence. see plan terms
  • A little about us

    Dudley’s Toffee is handcrafted English almond toffee made in small batches in Indiana using a cherished family recipe and simple ingredients. What makes our toffee unique is its softer, buttery texture that melts in your mouth instead of sticking to your teeth like traditional hard toffee.
    We offer both milk chocolate and dark chocolate varieties, each made with pure cane sugar and no high fructose corn syrup. Our products are also gluten free.
    What started as a family tradition of sharing homemade toffee with friends, church groups, and holiday gatherings has grown into a small business focused on creating high quality treats people genuinely remember and come back for.
    When you support Dudley’s Toffee, you’re supporting a small Indiana business that takes pride in handcrafted quality, personal connections, and making every batch with care.

    Frequently asked questions

    What makes Dudley’s Toffee different from traditional toffee?

    Dudley’s Toffee has a softer, buttery texture that melts in your mouth instead of sticking to your teeth like many traditional hard toffees. It’s handcrafted in small batches using a cherished family recipe.

    Is your toffee gluten free?

    Yes! Dudley’s Toffee is gluten free and made with simple ingredients, pure cane sugar, and no high fructose corn syrup.

    What flavors do you offer?

    We currently offer our handcrafted English almond toffee in Milk Chocolate and Dark Chocolate varieties.

    How should I store the toffee?

    Our toffee can be stored at room temperature for everyday enjoyment, but refrigeration can help extend freshness and maintain texture, especially in warmer weather.

    How long does the toffee stay fresh?

    Dudley’s Toffee typically stays fresh for up to 6 months at room temperature and over 18 months when refrigerated.

    Is Dudley’s Toffee good for gifting?

    Absolutely. Our handcrafted toffee is a popular gift for holidays, birthdays, corporate gifting, thank-you gifts, and special occasions.

    Where is Dudley’s Toffee made?

    Dudley’s Toffee is proudly handcrafted in small batches in Indiana.

    Do you offer local pickup or farmers market sales?

    Yes! You can often find Dudley’s Toffee at Indiana farmers markets and local events throughout the season. Event information is regularly updated on our website and social media pages.

    Shipping and policies

    Ships within 1-3 business days

    Returns accepted within 14 days

    These items aren’t available for delivery in your area.

    Ships from: Beech Grove, IN

    I’m here for any and all questions

  • Creator Avatar

    Meet Brian

    Owner of Dudley's Toffee, Beech Grove, IN

  • Hi, I’m Brian Stout, founder of Dudley’s Toffee. We handcraft small-batch English almond toffee in Indiana with a softer buttery crunch that won’t stick to your teeth.

    Experiences

    Add your review.

    Loyaltie is a better way to buy local.

    Buy from local businesses, makers, growers, and producers. Get quality of buying local, the joy of purchasing from actual people, the convenience of online shopping, and the confidence of Loyaltie backing every purchase.

    Save money. Buy local. Feel good.

    Support

    Help Center

    Loyaltie your business

    Who we're forAbout usPartnerships